McCarter Highway crashes in Newark
McCarter Highway had 110 crashes that killed or seriously hurt someone from January 1, 2019 to October 31, 2026, the most of any Newark road. 19 of them killed someone. 22 involved someone on foot. Counselworthy analysis of NJDOT crash records as of November 8, 2026.
- 19
- killed someone
- 91
- seriously hurt someone
- 4,129
- crashes of every kind
0.8 crashes that hurt someone per million miles driven, 2020 to 2023, 7th highest of 7 Newark roads with traffic counts. About 61,100 cars a day in 2023. Every road, per mile driven
20% involved someone on foot (22 of 110). Citywide, it was 32%.
Ride McCarter Highway corner by corner in the full street viewSee it on the crash map
Point at a cross street or a dot on the chart below to find it on the map.
Where on McCarter Highway
The most crashes of every kind were where it meets Clay Street, Bridge Street and Raymond Boulevard. Crashes that killed or seriously hurt someone were most often where it meets East 3rd Avenue: 11.
Swipe the chart sideways to follow the road.
Gray bars count every crash on McCarter Highway with a map location, from its south end to its north end. Dots are the 70 that killed or seriously hurt someone. Bigger dots killed someone. Cross streets are the ones police wrote most often, placed at the middle of their crashes.
Cross streets with the most crashes that killed or seriously hurt someone
- McCarter Highway at East 3rd Avenue11
- McCarter Highway at Market Street6
- McCarter Highway at Bridge Street5
- McCarter Highway at Chester Avenue4
- McCarter Highway at Miller Street4
Who gets hurt on McCarter Highway
71 of the 110 crashes involved only people in vehicles. That is 65%, against 54% for the whole city.
Crashes that killed or seriously hurt someone, January 2019 to October 2026. Each crash counts once: someone on foot, then on a bike, then a motorcycle.
McCarter Highway, year by year
The worst year was 2021, with 23. Counts jump around from year to year, so read single years with care.
* 2026 runs through October 2026. NJDOT calls these records preliminary. From September 2024, NJDOT's dashboard lists far fewer Newark crashes, so the years since undercount.
Other dangerous roads in Newark
Ranked by crashes that killed or seriously hurt someone, January 2019 to October 2026.
All Newark crash data- US 1 and 9, rank 2, 16 killed someone76
- Frelinghuysen Avenue, tied for rank 3, 10 killed someone51
- Broad Street, tied for rank 3, 6 killed someone51
- 1st Street, rank 5, 4 killed someone50
- Springfield Avenue, rank 6, 5 killed someone43
- Interstate 78, rank 7, 20 killed someone35
- Clinton Avenue, rank 8, 5 killed someone31
- Clifton Avenue, tied for rank 9, 3 killed someone27
- South Orange Avenue, tied for rank 9, no one killed27
Hurt in a crash on McCarter Highway?
General information, not legal advice. If you want a lawyer, compare the car accident firms we ranked in Newark before you call.
How we counted
- Every crash NJDOT's public crash dashboard (now its Crash Data Portal) lists for Newark from January 1, 2019 to October 31, 2026, saved November 8, 2026. NJDOT calls these records preliminary. New crashes can take weeks to appear, and older ones can change.
- Killed or seriously hurt means the worst injury in the crash was a death or a suspected serious injury, the top two of the five levels police use. We count crashes, not people.
- A crash counts toward McCarter Highway when the police report puts it there and inside Newark's limits, so only the stretch in Newark counts. Spellings of one road count as one, and the far side of a divided road counts as the same road.
- Cross streets are the ones police wrote on the reports. Places on the chart and the map are where NJDOT put each crash, or, where NJDOT gives no point, where the two streets on the report meet. 40 of the 110 crashes have no usable location; they still count in every total.
- The chart runs along the line that best fits the crash points, from the south end to the north end. On a road that bends, places along it are close, not exact.
- Counts are not adjusted for traffic or road length. A long, busy road will have more crashes. The rate per mile driven is (next note).
- Per mile driven divides the road's crashes that hurt someone, 2020 to 2023, by the miles driven on it: FHWA's traffic counts (the average cars a day New Jersey reports for each stretch), times the stretch's length, times the days, year by year. Only crashes beside a counted stretch count. A road gets a rate with a count on 80% of its length, 80% of its crashes beside a count, at least 20 crashes, and federal and state counts within a quarter of each other where both exist. Traffic counts are estimates, so a rate is too.
- From September 2024, NJDOT's dashboard lists far fewer Newark crashes: about 391 a month, against about 987 before. Years since then undercount.
- These are police reports. A crash nobody reported isn't here, including one where a driver left before a report was written. A hit-and-run counts when the report says a driver left the scene.
- Crash numbers never change a law firm's score.
Use this data
Free to reuse with credit to Counselworthy and a link to this page. In a video or a post, the short credit on screen or in the caption is enough. The crash file lists NJDOT's crash ID on every row, so anyone can check one.
Source: Counselworthy analysis of NJDOT police crash records, counselworthy.com
